| 1gordo1 | Deion Sanders |
| 1gordo1 | Alex Bregman |
| akorom77 | Ken Griffey Jr. |
| akorom77 | Willson Contreras |
| banball | Jeff Bagwell |
| banball | Matt Chapman |
| brendandearie5 | Gleyber Torres |
| brendandearie5 | Stephen Strasburg |
| chiroduffy | Buster Posey |
| chiroduffy | Barry Larkin |
| chrisking | Nolan Arenado |
| chrisking | Juan Soto |
| chrisking | Christian Yelich |
| chrisking | Kyle Schwarber |
| derekmortinsen | Mike Soroka |
| derekmortinsen | Derek Jeter |
| dickeyreed | Sonny Gray |
| dickeyreed | All Other Players |
| djfoleyin1 | Roger Clemens |
| djfoleyin1 | Steve Carlton |
| djfoleyin1 | Bob Gibson |
| djfoleyin1 | Cody Bellinger |
| drpr914 | Blake Snell |
| drpr914 | Adrian Beltre |
| fal | Keston Hiura |
| fal | Xander Bogaerts |
| fal | CC Sabathia |
| fal | Lou Brock |
| fal | Chris Sale |
| fal | Anthony Rizzo |
| fal | Ichiro |
| fal | Wade Boggs |
| fal | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. |
| fal | Shohei Ohtani |
| fal | Mike Trout |
| fal | David Ortiz |
| fal | Mark McGwire |
| fal | Carl Yastrzemski |
| Gonzo | Mariano Rivera |
| Gonzo | Aaron Judge |
| GriffeyJeter242 | Pedro Martinez |
| GriffeyJeter242 | Jack Flaherty |
| hess2131 | Albert Pujols |
| hess2131 | Max Muncy |
| jeremywilliams | Andrew Benintendi |
| jeremywilliams | Luis Robert |
| jessfox | Will Clark |
| jessfox | Elvis Andrus |
| JoBackson | Bo Bichette |
| JoBackson | Larry Walker |
| joerechtertig | Roberto Alomar |
| joerechtertig | Jose Altuve |
| johnmoulder | Chipper Jones |
| johnmoulder | Edgar Martinez |
| jrcox38 | Robin Yount |
| jrcox38 | Aaron Nola |
| JRSlatts | Austin Meadows |
| JRSlatts | Trevor Story |
| JRSlatts | Jacob deGrom |
| JRSlatts | Freddie Freeman |
| KSchwing44 | Corey Seager |
| KSchwing44 | Reggie Jackson |
| llagoe | Mike Schmidt |
| llagoe | Nolan Ryan |
| llagoe | Ronald Acuña Jr. |
| llagoe | Fernando Tatis Jr. |
| mathewstrope | Yordan Alvarez |
| mathewstrope | Ozzie Smith |
| mathewstrope | Ryne Sandberg |
| mathewstrope | Victor Robles |
| matthew.blankenstein | David Wright |
| matthew.blankenstein | Masahiro Tanaka |
| Mr.sgrant | A.J. Puk |
| Mr.sgrant | Don Mattingly |
| mtower5 | Rhys Hoskins |
| mtower5 | Hank Aaron |
| mtower5 | Frank Thomas |
| mtower5 | Randy Johnson |
| pcast003 | Carlton Fisk |
| pcast003 | Tom Glavine |
| phipsi40 | Jesus Luzardo |
| phipsi40 | Kyle Lewis |
| ryan.kehler | Johnny Bench |
| ryan.kehler | Bryce Harper |
| SergeantSkunk10 | Zac Gallen |
| SergeantSkunk10 | John Smoltz |
| SergeantSkunk10 | Walker Buehler |
| SergeantSkunk10 | Andy Pettitte |
| SergeantSkunk10 | Jim Thome |
| SergeantSkunk10 | George Springer |
| sn0331053 | Cal Ripken Jr. |
| sn0331053 | Joey Votto |
| sn0331053 | Whit Merrifield |
| sn0331053 | Alex Rodriguez |
| talonfoley | Rod Carew |
| talonfoley | Trevor Bauer |
| talonfoley | J.T. Realmuto |
| talonfoley | Rafael Devers |
| tomanek04 | Rickey Henderson |
| tomanek04 | DJ LeMahieu |
| treeder2 | Pete Alonso |
| treeder2 | Greg Maddux |
| vinnybarber | Aristides Aquino |
| vinnybarber | Miguel Cabrera |