| AlwaysHitless | Victor Robles |
| bgp100 | Bo Jackson |
| Blinded1 | Gary Sanchez |
| Bmoney | Dave Winfield |
| digman32736 | Ronald Acuna |
| digman32736 | Hank Aaron |
| digman32736 | Pedro Martinez |
| djfoleyin1 | Shohei Ohtani |
| fal | Amed Rosario |
| fal | Robin Yount |
| fal | Mike Piazza |
| fal | Mariano Rivera |
| fal | Francisco Lindor |
| fal | Frank Thomas |
| fal | Ozzie Smith |
| fal | Nomar Garciaparra |
| fal | Lou Brock |
| fal | Joey Votto |
| fal | Hideki Matsui |
| fal | Manny Machado |
| fal | Noah Syndergaard |
| fal | Andre Dawson |
| fal | Jose Ramirez |
| fal | Ryne Sandberg |
| fal | Bryce Harper |
| fal | David Ortiz |
| fal | Roberto Alomar |
| fal | Buster Posey |
| fal | Derek Jeter |
| fal | Jeff Bagwell |
| fal | Jim Palmer |
| fal | Mike Trout |
| fal | Reggie Jackson |
| fal | John Smoltz |
| fal | Johnny Bench |
| fal | Rafael Devers |
| fal | Barry Larkin |
| fal | Mark McGwire |
| fal | Anthony Rizzo |
| fal | Clint Frazier |
| fal | Chris Sale |
| fal | Gleyber Torres |
| fal | Randy Johnson |
| fal | Don Mattingly |
| fal | Adrian Beltre |
| fal | George Springer |
| fal | Cal Ripken Jr. |
| fal | Bernie Williams |
| fal | Andy Pettitte |
| fal | Frank Robinson |
| fal | Greg Maddux |
| fal | Brooks Robinson |
| fal | Craig Biggio |
| fal | Paul Goldschmidt |
| fal | Nolan Ryan |
| Geneklipp | Sandy Koufax |
| Geneklipp | Steve Carlton |
| jarynpaypal | Rod Carew |
| joew1153 | Al Kaline |
| joeyg2323 | Jose Altuve |
| JustShootMe | Clayton Kershaw |
| mkjauch | Carlton Fisk |
| mkoontz134 | Rhys Hoskins |
| pewgles | Aaron Judge |
| rossrob559 | All Other Players |
| ryuujin57 | Ozzie Albies |
| ryuujin57 | Wade Boggs |
| spikepoptart | Ichiro |
| talonfoley | Alex Rodriguez |
| tannen.john.wels | Albert Pujols |
| tannen.john.wels | Kris Bryant |
| tannen.john.wels | Tom Glavine |
| tannen.john.wels | Chipper Jones |